Checking date: 06/05/2025 08:45:19


Course: 2025/2026

Goverment policy evaluation
(13688)
Bachelor in Economics (2008 Study Plan) (Plan: 145 - Estudio: 202)


Coordinating teacher: STUHLER , JAN LEONARD

Department assigned to the subject: Economics Department

Type: Electives
ECTS Credits: 6.0 ECTS

Course:
Semester:




Requirements (Subjects that are assumed to be known)
Requirements: - Core courses in Microeconomics, Macroeconomics and Econometrics, as part of a standard Economics degree, at an intermediate level. - Since the course places much emphasis on the motivation for and applicability of quantitative methods it is required that students successfully completed courses in Econometrics and Applied Economics (or equivalent courses), which are compulsory in the second and third year of the Grado del Economía at the Universidad Carlos III de Madrid.
Objectives
Objective: To study methods used for the evaluation of economic policies in theory and practice.
Learning Outcomes
K1: Understand democratic principles and values, as well as the Sustainable Development Goals, with special emphasis on respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms, gender equality, non-discrimination, universal accessibility principles, and the fight against climate change. K3: Acquire knowledge of the theories and techniques specific to Economics, employing appropriate terminology and the scientific method. K5: Know quantitative and qualitative research techniques, and be able to discern which are the most appropriate to apply in the field of economics. K6: Comprehend the economic and social impact of various public policies on different agents and in diverse socioeconomic contexts. S2: Exploit information by interpreting relevant data, avoiding plagiarism, and adhering to academic and professional conventions within the field of study, with the ability to evaluate the reliability and quality of the information. S6: Identify, collect, interpret and manage relevant information on economic issues, using the appropriate concepts and methodologies of analysis. S9: Derive relevant economic information from the data, and be able to process it to answer the questions of interest S12: Model and quantitatively interpret specific economic issues C5: Use appropriate statistical and econometric tools to address and solve economic problems. C6: Integrate democratic principles and values, as well as the Sustainable Development Goals, into the professional sphere.
Description of contents: programme
1.- Introduction Introduction and Motivation Definitions: Economic policies and treatment; treatment effects and causality (causal parameters of interest); control and treatment groups; observed and potential or counterfactual outcomes. Notation. Problems in the identification and estimation of treatment effects, and their relationship to traditional econometric techniques. 2.- Randomized Experiments in the Social Sciences Definitions and conditions of a randomized experiment. The advantages of randomization and how it enables the estimation of treatment effects. Information from other variables: the possibility to verify successful randomization and to study the existence of heterogeneous treatment effects. Problems and limitations of randomized experiments. Examples and Applications: - The effect of class size on educational outcomes (Project STAR). - The NSW training and subsidy program for unemployed workers (Ham y LaLonde, 1996). Effect on the probability of finding work? Effect on wages? 3.- Observational Studies and Matching Estimators Exogeneity, matching and multiple regression. Extrapolation. Matching based on the probability to be treated (Propensity Score Matching). Assumptions; estimation of the propensity score; estimator and algorithms; testing for common support. Examples and Applications: - Job Training Partnership Act: A program that provides job training and assistance in finding jobs for people in poverty. - The NSW training and subsidy program for unemployed workers (Dehejia and Wahba, 1999) 4.- Natural or Quasi-natural Experiments Exploit natural events or policy changes to identify the effect of treatment on the treated. Differences over time. The Difference-in-Differences Estimator: a basic estimator for repeated cross-sections and panel data; common or varying trends; additional regressors. Event study and heterogenous effects in the DiD estimator. Examples and Applications: - The effect of immigration on labor markets: the Mariel Boatlift (Card, 1990). - The effect of minimum wages on employment (Card and Krueger, 1994). 5.- Using Instrumental Variables to Estimate Treatment Effects The instrumental variable (IV) estimator using data from experiments and quasi-experiments. Wald estimator. Two-stage least square estimator. Interpretation of the IV estimator with homogeneous or heterogeneous treatment effects; eligibility rule; the local average treatment effect (LATE); the monotonicity condition. Limitations. Marginal Treatment Effects (if time allows). Examples and Applications: - The Vietnam Draft Lottery: The effect of military service during the Vietnam War on civilian wages (Angrist, 1990). - The impact of a Child care program Hogares Comunitarios on nutrition and health (Attanasio, Di Maro, y Vera-Hernandez, 2010 and 2013). 6.- Regression Discontinuity Designs Sharp and fuzzy regression discontinuity (RD) designs. Continuity in potential outcomes and testable implications. The interpretation and estimation of fuzzy regression discontinuity designs by IV estimator. Parametric and non-parametric implementation. Local linear regression. Examples and Applications: - The effect of class size on test scores in reading and maths (Angrist and Lavy, 1999). 7.- The Estimation of Structural Models Advantages and Disadvantages of atheoretical vs. structural approaches. The estimation of structural models. The importance and justification for dynamic models. General equilibrium effects and models. Example: The impact of a school subsidy program: the use of experimental data to validate a model of dynamic behavior of education and fertility decisions. (Todd and Wolpin, American Economics Review, 2006)
Learning activities and methodology
Practical Classes and Problem Sets: The first practical classes will give an introduction to the software STATA. In the rest of the course we work on problem sets that contain both theoretical problems and applications. We use STATA to study actual data.
Assessment System
  • % end-of-term-examination/test 60
  • % of continuous assessment (assigments, laboratory, practicals...) 40

Calendar of Continuous assessment


Extraordinary call: regulations
Basic Bibliography
  • A. Cameron and P. Trivedi.. Chapter 25 de Microeconometrics: Methods and Practice. Cambridge University Press.
  • J. Angrist and J. Pischke. Mostly Harmless Econometrics. Princeton University Press.
  • Raquel Bernal and Ximena Peña. Guía Práctica Para La Evaluación De Impacto (in Spanish). Ediciones UC. ISBN: 978-958-695-599-7
  • References to specific . topics will be given . in class throughout. the course.
Additional Bibliography
  • Angrist.J;Krueger.A. Instrumental variables and the search for identification. Journal of Economic Perspectives. 2001
  • Angrist.J;Pischke.J . The Credibility Revolution in Empirical Economics. Journal of Economic Perspectives. 2010
  • Bleemer.Z;Mehta.A. Will Studying Economics Make you Rich?. American Economic Journal: Applied Economics. 2022
  • Borjas G.. The Wage Impact of the Marielitos A Reappraisal. ILR Review. 2017
  • Card D.. The Impact of the Mariel Boatlift on the Miami Labor Market.pdf. Industrial and Labor Relations Review. 1990
  • Card.D;Krueger.A. Minimum Wages and Employment A Case Study. American Economic Review. 1994
  • Deaton A.. Instruments, Randomization, and Learning about Development. 2010. Journal of Economic Literature
  • Deaton, A.. Instruments, Randomization, and Learning about Development. Journal of Economic Literature. 2010
  • Dehejia.R;Wahba.S. Causal Effects in Nonexperimental Studies. Journal of the American Statistical Association. 1999
  • Imbens G.. Better LATE than nothing. Journal of Economic Literature. 2010
  • LaLonde R.. Evaluating the Econometric Evaluations of Training Programs with Experimental Data. American Economic Review. 1986
  • Leamer E.. Let's Take the Con out of Econometrics. American Economic Review. 1983
  • Lee D.. Randomized Experiments from Non-random Selection in US House Elections. Journal of Econometrics. 2008
  • Minimum Wages and Employment: A Case Study of the Fast-Food Industry in New Jersey and Pennsylvania. Minimum Wages and Employment A Case Study. American Economic Review. 1994
  • Roth.J;Sant¿Anna.P;Bilinski.A. What¿s Trending in Difference-in-Differences?. Journal of Econometrics. 2023

The course syllabus may change due academic events or other reasons.